View Full Version: Sasuke x Hinata : Second Theory - The Five Elements

nocturnaltravel >>SasuHina GENERAL >>Sasuke x Hinata : Second Theory - The Five Elements


july_winter- 04-13-2007
Sasuke x Hinata : Second Theory - The Five Elements
Scribble: The author reserves the right to modify this theory accordingly, depending on the recent events from Naruto manga and/or for purely theoretical development. Please be guided that this is only a theory and not a fact. Important Note: This theory is based on the Five Elements of Japanese Mythology. It is slightly different from the Five Elements of Chinese Mythology and should not be confused with it. The Five Elements based on Japanese mythology: ... fire > wind > sky/heaven > earth > water > fire ... (cycle) The Five Elements of Naruto: In Naruto, sky/heaven is seemingly specified as lightning. ... fire > wind > lightning > earth > water > fire ... (cycle) The elements fire and sky/heaven are associated with yang. The Uchiha specialize in the element of fire. Consistently, this is manifested by Sasuke as well as the element of lightning (chidori). Note that the element sky/heaven in Japanese myth is synonymous to lightning in Naruto. The elements water and wind are associated with yin. The Hyuga are yet to show any elemental affinity, if at all. Note, however, that the Hyuga divination field is similar to the bagua, the ultimate device in Chinese geomancy (feng shui, literally wind water). Wind and water are believed to direct qi (energy) - wind carries energy, representing the principle of change and transformation; water withholds energy, representing stability and inner strength. The principle of change of the wind may be portrayed by Neji; the principle of inner strength of water may be portrayed by Hinata. One filler arc pointed out that Hinata uses water to sharpen her absolute defense but it is still considered unofficial. The element left out is earth which may either be viewed as: 1. The balance of yin and yang together; or 2. A metaphor of yin that is matched by sky/heaven metaphor of yang. NOTES (1) During the chuunin exams at the Forest of Death, Team 7 was given the scroll of Heaven. (2) Orochimaru gave Sasuke the Seal of Heaven. Kimimaro has the Seal of Earth. Disclaimers Naruto is a property of Kishimoto Masashi. Manga published by Shueisha. Anime produced by Studio Pierrot. Last edited on: 30 April 2008. Reason: Deleted redundancy.

baka_dark- 12-29-2007

soo... u think hinata is yin if she is a water user and sasuke is a fire user n that's yin n yang? but wat does the scroll have to do with anything all the other teams has the same scroll

HinaMatsuri- 12-29-2007

soo... u think hinata is yin if she is a water user and sasuke is a fire user n that's yin n yang? but wat does the scroll have to do with anything all the other teams has the same scroll I hope July_winter doesn't mind, I'll explain the theory to you. You see, the most common elements for Yin and Yang are Water and Fire. If Kishimoto truly presents that Hinata is the representation of water, then we'll practically have an offical. But even if Kishimoto decides that water is not her element, Hinata is still a likely canidate for Yin, due to her colors (hair and eyes) and personality. Not to mention, wind appears to be on Neji and Hinata's side, because wind is an element for Yin as well. On the Heaven and Earth Scroll, July_winter was just pointing out that Sasuke appears to be full-blown Yang, because everything for him, appears to fall inside the category of Yang. Personality and all. lol Am...am I correct July_winter..? :oops:

july_winter- 12-30-2007

soo... u think hinata is yin if she is a water user and sasuke is a fire user n that's yin n yang? but wat does the scroll have to do with anything all the other teams has the same scroll Thank you for the feedback. It still is unknown if Hinata will ever manifest any elemental affinity. Hopefully, she is a water user. In the chuunin exams, the rule goes that all teams are to receive either a Heaven or Earth scroll; the teams were tasked to steal from others the scroll that they do not have. Important Note: Heaven is yang ; Earth is yin. Team 7 received the scroll of Heaven, which means that Sasuke consistently fits the definition of yang. It was never shown what scroll Team 8 received. IF Hinata is yin, they should have received the scroll of Earth. ... On the Heaven and Earth Scroll, July_winter was just pointing out that Sasuke appears to be full-blown Yang, because everything for him, appears to fall inside the category of Yang. Personality and all... :thumb Disclaimers Naruto is a property of Kishimoto Masashi. Manga published by Shueisha. Anime produced by Studio Pierrot.

july_winter- 04-05-2008

? Wind (yin) = Wood (yang) ? Sometimes, the Japanese element of wind is equated to the Chinese element of wood, which causes confusion because wind is (theoretically) yin and wood is yang. Clarifications This theory assumes that wind element is yin based on the wind trigram from the bagua. 1. First, note the difference between the Chinese and Japanese Five Elements philosophies. The Five Elements based on Chinese mythology: ... fire > metal > wood > earth > water > fire ... (cycle) The Five Elements based on Japanese mythology: ... fire > wind > >sky/heaven > earth > water > fire ... (cycle) In I Ching, all are directly correlated except: Metal (yin) : Sky/Heaven (yang) Wood (yang) : Wind (yin) This relationship may be found by taking a closer look at the eight trigrams. Each trigram has a specific polarity (yin/yang) and a corresponding (Chinese) classical element. Among the last two correlations, observe that: - the trigram of Sky/Heaven (yang) is correlated to the element of Metal (yin). - the trigram of Wind (yin) is correlated to the element of Wood (yang). The trigram polarity is constant. Hence, although wind is sometimes equated to wood, wind being yin is independent of wood being yang. 2. More often, wood is yang and metal is yin. However, fictionally, Yamato’s wood affinity is a combination of water and earth. - the trigram of Water (yin) is correlated to the element of Water (yin). - the trigram of Earth (yin) is correlated to the element of Earth (balance of yin and yang). Logically then: water (yin) + earth (yin/balance of yin and yang) = wood (yin) Reversal of elemental polarity (specifically, wood becomes yin / metal becomes yang) can occur in I Ching. Again, the corresponding trigrams' polarities are constant and will not be affected. This is taken into consideration, Wood (yin) = Wind (yin) Metal (yang) = Sky/Heaven (yang) NOTES The similarities between Hyuga and Uchiha prodigies (examples, Neji and Sasuke) may be pointed out using the concept of the Five Elements, where the Hyuga can be indirectly associated to yang via wind (yin) = wood (yang). However, the Hyuga manifests yang much less than the Uchiha.

Mysticwish123- 07-05-2008

it is said that team 8 recieved the heaven scroll. but this could speculate something else, I don't know haha =P

july_winter- 07-05-2008

it is said that team 8 recieved the heaven scroll. ... Thanks for the correction! Henceforth, the following statement found in post #4 is declared FALSE. ... IF Hinata is yin, they should have received the scroll of Earth... AT 'OPPOSING ENDS' ? ... but this could speculate something else... This may (or may not) be another look at it :wink: Team Seven Given scroll: Scroll of Heaven, of which they lost to Orochimaru. Last scroll: Scroll of Heaven. After obtaining a Scroll of Earth from Sound nins, the team had to search for the scroll akin to their original one to complete the exams. Amongst the Konoha teams who passed the exams, they made it to the tower last. Team Eight Given scroll: Scroll of Heaven. Last scroll: Scroll of Earth. Amongst the Konoha teams who passed the exams, they made it to the tower first. * Although they may have been given the same original scrolls, note the last scrolls they obtained. Disclaimer Naruto is property of Kishimoto Masashi. Manga published by Shueisha. Anime produced by Studio Pierrot.

Forumer™ is Voted #1 Free Forum Hosting provider
Build your own community today with the largest message board hosting company.